4 stars because:One broke on the first day my 9 year old daughter wore these. She brought the pieces home in her pocket. Maybe we received a faulty pair, because my two toddlers still have them attached to their coats! If these can hold up for very young kids at preschool, then I would recommend them for sure.Also, these actually stay put! I would give 5 stars if one had not broken on the first day. I will update after the return process and new ones have arrived.My son can not pull his gloves off these. Such a time saver! No more looking for gloves in the yard and thrown over the side of the stroller on walks. Glad these were available online, could not find in stores.My kids never wear their gloves out to school at recess because they "don't have time to find them" so I decided to give these a whirl. Three kids between 3 and 7 and have yet to have one fall off even at school. This doesn't guarantee the kids will wear their gloves, but at least they can't complain about it now. I also like that it keeps my younger one from losing his gloves. It does make it a little trickier to get the gloves on until they get used to them being attached, but they seem to have mostly figured it out. Great product!Good length, but its grip doesn't hold up well to the kid swinging the gloves around at the end of her sleeves like nunchucks.I love using these for my son to ensure he does not lose his mittens at school. They are pretty sturdy but we have had a few break.These worked great to lose gloves less frequently for my 6yo at school. We ended up still losing one of each pattern. But they lasted longer than if we didn’t have the clips. We will probably buy another set next year. Or whenever our now mismatched pair gets lost. They aren’t foolproof since my 6yo knows how to take them off. And also can pop off if pulled hard enough. But for the most part these work very well. We’re very happy with this purchase!One of the clips that my daughter had previously had lost its grip, so I bought these to replace them. I will be sure to always have some of these on hand because I don't expect my 4 year old to keep up with a pair of mittens.Works great for a while, but clasps stretch out and mittens slip out of teeth. One of them broke apart after one day.Love em!